Arrested After Passing DUI Roadside Tests? The Shocking Truth

The truth is, these roadside evaluations are not designed for you to pass. They are designed to gather specialized, visual evidence to justify an arrest that the officer may have already decided to make.

The Reality Behind Roadside Evaluations

When a law enforcement officer pulls a driver over on suspicion of driving under the influence in Florida, they typically administer three standard physical exercises at the roadside:

The Walk-and-Turn Test: Walking heel-to-toe along a straight line, turning in a very specific manner, and counting aloud.
The One-Leg Stand Test: Balancing on one foot while keeping the other raised six inches off the ground and counting.
The Finger-to-Nose Test: Tilting your head back, closing your eyes, and bringing the tip of your index finger directly to the tip of your nose.

These exercises are almost always recorded on police cruiser dashboard cameras or body-worn cameras. However, these are not standard “pass/fail” physical challenges. They are complex multi-tasking tests designed to look for minute clues or “indicators” of impairment—such as starting too early, raising your arms for balance by a couple of inches, or miscounting a step.

Because the exercises are highly unnatural and technical, they are incredibly difficult to perform flawlessly, even for someone who is completely sober and dealing with the extreme nervousness of a flashing police encounter.
YouTube

Why the Officer’s Discretion Wins at the Roadside

Ultimately, whether you “passed” or “failed” the exercises at the scene is not decided by a score sheet or an objective machine—it is entirely up to the subjective opinion of the arresting officer. If the officer notes a odor of alcohol, bloodshot eyes, or slurred speech, they can discount your physical performance entirely and make the arrest based on their total observations. Your perceived success on those tests does not prevent handcuffs from coming out, but the recorded video footage of your steady balance can become the most powerful evidence your defense attorney uses to dismantle the prosecution’s case in court.

Video Transcript Summary

Can you be arrested for a DUI even though you passed the field sobriety tests? Yes. Under Florida’s DUI laws, there are three exercises typically given by officers at the roadside: the walk-and-turn test, the stand-on-one-leg test, and the finger-to-nose test. These are usually captured on video. They are not easy to perform, even if you are completely sober. So even though you may think you passed the field sobriety tests, you can still be arrested for DUI. Ultimately, it is entirely up to the officer’s subjective opinion at the scene.

Fight an Unjust Roadside Arrest in Tampa Bay

If you were arrested despite performing well on your roadside exercises, your case is far from over. The video footage captured by police cameras can be aggressively used to challenge the officer’s probable cause for arrest. As a Board-Certified Criminal Trial Specialist and former prosecutor, W.F. “Casey” Ebsary Jr. knows how to turn roadside video evidence into a powerful defense tool.

Review our specialized strategies About Our Courtroom Experience
Contact Our Tampa Office Immediately to have your roadside video evaluated by a specialist.
Call Casey at 813-222-2220

You can review our complete breakdown of roadside evaluation flaws by watching this video analysis on Passed Sobriety Tests Arrests, which details how police officers evaluate physical indicators at the scene.

Call 813-222-2220